Deconstruction and ‘Re-Volumization’: The Thomason Collection in the Past, Present, and Future
Name
eBLJ_2023_article11_Mendle_M_VoR_BY.pdf
Description
visibility:open
Size
240.02 KB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (CRC64NVME)
+CjSigj8LX0=
Resource type
Journal article
Creator (person)
Mendle, Michael
Date published
January 29, 2024
Abstract
The Thomason Tracts that arrived at the British Museum as the gift of George III were in a rigorous chronological order, which was mirrored by Thomason’s own twelve-volume manuscript catalogue. Though Thomason boasted that by means of the catalogue even a single sheet could be found ‘instantly’, even more important was that the collection and catalogue’s organization encouraged chronological browsing, an immersion into the swirling currents of the day. Early readers, having only the manuscript catalogue and the chronology-based numbering of volumes, understood this well. Foremost among the mid-nineteenth century readers and publicists of the collection was Thomas Carlyle, whose correct intuitions about the collection were matched by his frightful manners. Carlyle provoked a mighty conflict with the Museum’s great librarian and cataloguer Antonio Panizzi. Panizzi’s priorities as cataloguer, custodian, and reading room supervisor clashed violently with Carlyle’s - especially in Panizzi’s fortunately aborted design to disbind the collection, whose chronological organization Panizzi never appreciated. The chronological browsing fostered by the collection served readers well from William Godwin, Carlyle, and S. R. Gardiner to the many who read the tracts in the old North Library, and, later, in the microfilm edition. Early English Books Online (EEBO), however, by its very design effectively disbinds the collection. Newer students unfamiliar with the now-buried Thomason volumes have little or no understanding of collection’s value as a chronological collection. But there are research techniques to mitigate the harm - ‘re-volumization’ - and restore the full brilliance of Thomason’s achievement.
Journal title
Electronic British Library Journal
Volume
2023
Article number
11
Publisher
British Library
Place of publication
London, UK
eISSN
1478-0259
Date accepted
March 3, 2023
Official URL
Rights statement
In Copyright
Keywords
Additional information
Author note: Michael Mendle is Professor Emeritus of History in the University of Alabama. He is the author of Dangerous Positions: Mixed Government, the Estates of the Realm, and the Making of the Answer to the 19 Propositions (1985), and of Henry Parker and the English Civil War: The Political Thought of the Public’s ‘Privado’ (1995). His essays have explored both the political thought and the print culture of the English Revolution, as well as the nature and history of the Thomason collection, not least in ‘George Thomason’s Intentions’, in Giles Mandlebrote and Barry Taylor (eds.), Libraries within the Library (2009). Among his current interests are the nineteenth- and twentieth-century reception of seventeenth-century sources into the historiographic canon, and the early history of English shorthand.
Collection